Skip to content

Independent Investigative Journalism for New Jersey

Get our free newsletter → Bold reporting for a brighter New Jersey
The Jersey Vindicator logoThe Jersey Vindicator
Email Signal messenger iconBluesky social media iconLinkedin Facebook Instagram RSS

  • Bill TrackerExpand
    • Bill search tool
    • Latest New Jersey bills
    • Top bill sponsors
    • Call It! Play our bill guessing game
  • State Government
  • Criminal Justice
  • HealthcareExpand
    • 🔍 NJ Nursing Home Owner Search Tool
    • 🔍 NJ Nursing Home Owners – Other States
  • Environment
  • Immigration
  • News In Brief
  • Elections
  • New Jersey VoicesExpand
    • The Public Record
    • What’s Left
    • Pinelands Matters
The Jersey Vindicator logoThe Jersey Vindicator

Courts Transparency

New Jersey federal judge evicts journalists from court press room

BySteve Janoski May 29, 2025December 16, 2025
EmailSubscribeWhatsAppSMSShare
The U.S. District Courthouse for the District of New Jersey in Newark. Photo by Andres Kudacki for The Jersey Vindicator.

Members of the New Jersey press corps reporting from the Newark federal courthouse will have to find another place from which to file their stories after a judge stripped them of the right to use the building’s press room.

In a May 21 directive, Chief U.S. District Judge Renée Marie Bumb cited unspecified safety, security and spatial concerns as the reason for her decision.

The order also rescinded any “exceptional access” previously granted to the press in federal court buildings across the state.

“The press room on the third floor of the Martin Luther King Building & U.S. Courthouse … shall be returned to the Court for its official judiciary business,” the order stated.

It is unclear whether a specific threat prompted the order, which took effect immediately. Reporters were left without a dedicated space to work in the courthouse.

Never miss a story. Sign up for our free newsletter.

Calls to Bumb’s chambers and the courthouse were not returned on Thursday.

Bruce Rosen, a media lawyer with the Hackensack-based firm Pashman Stein Walder Hayden, said the move is part of a broader pattern that has reduced public access to the judiciary.

“I think it’s terrible,” said Rosen, a former reporter who once worked in the courthouse. “The federal courts need to be more transparent. They’ve become more insular — whether that’s because of security, the demands of the job, or because they no longer feel they have to be transparent.”

“If people aren’t using the press room, there’s no reason to reserve the room,” he said. “But if people are using the press room, it’s pretty inexcusable.”

The judge’s decision comes as state officials consider new rules that would prohibit the press and public from using a taxpayer-funded parking garage at the New Jersey State House. Critics say the change would effectively force them to park elsewhere and walk through Trenton’s streets, which some have described as unsafe.

Eric Brophy, chair of the State Capitol Joint Management Commission, cited security concerns and the guidance of the New Jersey State Police in supporting the proposal.

“They’re the law enforcement and security experts; we’re not,” Brophy told reporters. “So we’re following the lead of the experts. They explained to us what the security plan is and why they’re doing it.”

Brophy did not cite any specific threats. He grew combative when pressed by reporters.

Later, State Police Superintendent Col. Patrick Callahan said in an email that the recommendation came from the New Jersey Office of Homeland Security and Preparedness, but added that the commission will make the final decision.

“The decision does not rest on the NJSP; we only weigh in on security measures,” he wrote. “The [commission] makes the final decision.”

Before you go, can you help us continue to do in-depth reporting for a better New Jersey?

The team at The Jersey Vindicator is dedicated to journalism that informs and empowers residents, spotlights truth, advances accountabilty, and sparks change. If you value our work, please support us with a tax-deductible donation of any amount.

Yes, I’ll chip in!
Steve Janoski

Steve Janoski is a multi-award-winning journalist whose work has appeared in the New York Post, USA Today, the Associated Press, The Bergen Record and the Asbury Park Press. His reporting has exposed corruption, government malfeasance and police misconduct

Share this story!

  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • Share on Bluesky (Opens in new window) Bluesky
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Share on Nextdoor (Opens in new window) Nextdoor
  • Print (Opens in new window) Print

Post navigation

Previous Previous
A Revolutionary War battlefield in New Jersey is getting a $5 million restoration
NextContinue
A year of living dangerously: Connaught Hill still in jeopardy

The Jersey Vindicator is a proud member of the following organizations:

Institute for Nonprofit News member badge
Association of Alternative Newsmedia logo
SPJ New Jersey chapter logo
New Jersey Center for Nonprofit Journalism logo
News Commons member badge
New Jersey Civic Information Consortium member badge
The Jersey Vindicator logo in white

Independent Investigative Journalism for New Jersey. Free for everyone, funded by readers.

  • Republishing our stories
  • Conflicts of interest
  • Donor transparency
  • Editorial independence
  • Journalistic ethics
  • Collaborations
  • How to contact us
  • Our mission
  • Contributors
  • How we’re funded
  • How to support our work

© 2026 The New Jersey Center for Nonprofit Journalism

Email Bluesky social network butterfly logoLinkedin Facebook Instagram RSS Signal private messenger logo
  • Bill Tracker
    • Bill search tool
    • Latest New Jersey bills
    • Top bill sponsors
    • Call It! Play our bill guessing game
  • State Government
  • Criminal Justice
  • Healthcare
    • 🔍 NJ Nursing Home Owner Search Tool
    • 🔍 NJ Nursing Home Owners – Other States
  • Environment
  • Immigration
  • News In Brief
  • Elections
  • New Jersey Voices
    • The Public Record
    • What’s Left
    • Pinelands Matters
Search
Share to...
FacebookBlueskyThreadsRedditXLinkedInMessengerNextdoorFlipboardPrintMastodon