NJ attorney general sues Department of Homeland Security over Delaney Hall records
The state is seeking medical and use-of-force records as part of a civil rights investigation related to the deaths of three men who were detained at the Newark facility.

New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport sued the U.S. Department of Homeland Security on Tuesday, saying federal officials have gone more than three months without saying whether the private company that runs Delaney Hall can turn over records about the treatment of people held at the Newark immigration detention center.
Attorney General Jennifer Davenport and Yolanda Melville, director of the state Division on Civil Rights, asked a federal judge in Washington, D.C., to give federal officials seven days to tell New Jersey and GEO Group whether the company can turn over the records. The GEO Group operates Delaney Hall.
The lawsuit also names U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, and acting ICE Director David Venturella as defendants.
“There are far too many reports of inhumane treatment of the people held at Delaney Hall. But what we have received for months from both GEO Group and DHS is plain stonewalling,” Davenport said in a statement. “We will continue to do all we can to ensure that these civil detainees are treated with the dignity and decency that all people are entitled to under the law.”
The state opened an investigation Aug. 7 to determine whether GEO Group violated detainees’ rights under the New Jersey Civil Rights Act and the New Jersey Law Against Discrimination. Investigators subpoenaed records on how staff screen and treat detainees, what qualifications medical staff hold, how the facility plans to contain infectious diseases, and when guards used force.
The GEO Group declined to turn over the records on Aug. 21, the day they were due. A lawyer for GEO said the subpoena was forwarded to Homeland Security because, in the company’s view, federal rules require approval before the company can release records from its work for ICE. In a Sept. 3 letter filed with the lawsuit, a GEO Group lawyer wrote that requests for records about detention or medical care “necessitate review and approval by ICE.”
Lawyers for the state argue that GEO Group, a private business operating on its own property, can comply with a state subpoena without federal approval. Even if the federal rules apply to some records, lawyers for the state said the company still should be able to provide its medical staff training manuals and say whether its health care providers are licensed in New Jersey.
The state sent federal officials a copy of the subpoena Sept. 29 and asked for a response by Oct. 7. Investigators followed up Oct. 20, describing evidence from witness statements, medical records, and other documents and asking for a decision by Nov. 5. New Jersey officials said neither letter received a response. They argue that the delay violates the federal Administrative Procedure Act.
“These repeated inquiries have been met with silence,” state lawyers wrote in the complaint. “Not only has DHS failed to authorize the production of any information, but it has refused even to confirm whether it will or will not authorize GEO Group to produce responsive material.”
State investigators say they have received reports of detainees going without medication for chronic conditions and staff failing to respond adequately to medical emergencies. In their Oct. 20 letter, investigators said they had found “numerous instances in which detainees required emergency hospital care after receiving care from GEO that may have been inadequate or unduly delayed.”
The complaint also describes reports of excessive force by guards, sexual assault, and a lack of accommodations that people with disabilities needed for their safety. Investigators said detainees were “routinely denied access to language interpretation,” including during medical screenings and when asked to sign forms for their immigration cases.
An ICE inspection in September identified 22 deficiencies under federal detention standards, according to the complaint. The deficiencies included problems with medical and mental health screenings for people arriving at the facility, access to prescription medication, and procedures for preventing and responding to sexual abuse.
“Individuals housed in an immigration detention facility do not waive their constitutional and legal right to receive adequate medical care or to be protected from violence,” Melville said in a statement. “People who have been held at Delaney Hall have shared extremely troubling accounts, as have the families of those who died. The federal government’s silence in response to our lawful requests for information speaks volumes.”
The complaint cites an internal ICE review that found medical staff failed to recognize signs of cardiac arrest in Jean Wilson Brutus, who died Dec. 12, 2025, less than 24 hours after he arrived at Delaney Hall. Another man, Jose Chajon-Raxon, was taken to a hospital in July after experiencing seizure-like symptoms at the facility.
ICE did not publicly disclose Chajon-Raxon’s death before U.S. Rep. Rob Menendez made it public in August. A Homeland Security spokesperson told The Jersey Vindicator that ICE had released Chajon-Raxon before he died and that the agency’s policy is to monitor and review only deaths that occur in its custody.
The third man, Edwin Jovanny Lopez-Cornejo, died Aug. 1. His family said he had diabetes and high blood pressure and went without prescribed medication during the roughly six weeks he was detained, according to the complaint.
“Additional detainees are at substantial risk of becoming sick or dying because of Delaney Hall’s reportedly sub-standard conditions,” state lawyers wrote.
Homeland Security officials have repeatedly said that detainees receive proper medical care.
A separate lawsuit over access to Delaney Hall remains pending. New Jersey sued GEO Group in June after state health inspectors were allowed into the kitchen but were kept out of the medical unit, sleeping areas, and bathrooms.
Krystal Knapp is the founder, executive director, and publisher of The Jersey Vindicator and the founder of Planet Princeton. She has more than two decades of experience reporting in New Jersey, including 10 years at The Trenton Times, where she was the newsroom’s public records and computer-assisted reporting expert. Her work has been recognized by the New Jersey Press Association and the Center for Cooperative Media. You can reach her at Krystal AT jerseyvindicator.org.

