NJ presses ICE for answers on Roxbury detention site
State officials say federal authorities have not answered questions about a $31.8 million contract tied to the warehouse.
State officials are accusing federal immigration authorities of stonewalling their requests for information about a planned detention center in Roxbury. State officials have threatened further court action if the situation doesn’t change.
The Department of Homeland Security, which bought a 470,000-square-foot warehouse off Route 46 in February, agreed to halt all conversion work at the site and conduct an environmental assessment under the National Environmental Policy Act after the state and Roxbury sued to block the project.
But state officials say recent actions by DHS, including processing detainees in the warehouse parking lot and signing a $31.8 million contract for the site with a Tennessee-based firm, have raised questions about whether the agency is complying with the agreement.
“Defendants may not commit resources to work that would convert the warehouse site into a detention center without first conducting the required environmental reviews,” state Attorney General Jennifer Davenport wrote in a nine-page joint status report filed Nov. 16 in U.S. District Court.
“But if defendants have already committed resources to converting the facility, then any forthcoming [environmental assessment] will be mere window dressing for a decision that has already been made — subjecting plaintiffs to a wide range of infrastructure, environmental, and public health harms without the required review,” Davenport wrote.
In a brief reply, attorneys from the Department of Justice wrote that federal officials hired the firm to maintain the property, design ICE’s preferred plan for converting the warehouse into a detention center, and conduct the environmental review.
Federal officials told state and local officials that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) plans to renovate the warehouse for some level of detention capacity, among other uses, in accordance with the court order.
Immigration authorities are still working on fulfilling the state’s request to review the contract in time to submit a court-mandated status report, according to the status report.
The filing means that the state and federal governments remain deadlocked over the controversial proposal to build a detention center that would house somewhere between 500 and 1,500 detainees in the Morris County town.
Questions also remain about whether DHS is complying with a May court order barring work to convert the warehouse into a detention center until an environmental review is completed and state and local officials have a chance to challenge the findings.
After the order was issued, federal officials told the court that DHS had decided not to pursue a detention center on the property, which the government bought for $129.3 million. But two weeks later, the agency reversed itself and said administrators had not yet decided what they wanted to do.
Roxbury, a Republican-dominated town, joined the state’s March lawsuit to block the project after residents and activists raised concerns about the proposed detention center. The suit accused ICE officials of ignoring federal laws requiring environmental reviews and consultations with state and local governments before moving ahead with plans.
Some residents and activists have pushed township officials to do more. Protesters disrupted last week’s Roxbury Township Council meeting and called on officials to do more to stop the detention center. One activist accused council members of doing only the minimum necessary to enforce the court order. Mayor Shawn Potillo defended the township’s response, saying local officials oppose the project and are fighting it in court.
Under a May consent order, ICE said it would do only basic maintenance and security work until the environmental review is complete and the other conditions of the order are met.
But ICE officials later admitted that agents from its Newark Enforcement and Removal Operations Field Office brought 14 undocumented immigrants to the warehouse on two occasions after raids in Dover and Ledgewood. The activity stopped only after the field office director told underlings to end the practice.
State and local officials have repeatedly asked to review the multimillion-dollar contract, as well as information about ICE’s activities at the site. State officials first requested a copy of the contract Nov. 6 and sought additional clarification Nov. 10. Federal officials agreed to provide it, but state officials had not received the contract when the status report was filed.
The defendants, including ICE, DHS and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, have yet to answer other questions about the contract and their activities at the warehouse, according to the attorney general.
Federal attorneys disputed the state’s characterization of their response, saying they answered an initial request for information about the contract within three hours.
“Although defendants have denied holding individuals inside the warehouse and have represented that they will no longer use the warehouse site in connection with enforcement actions, they still have not answered questions plaintiffs raised more than three weeks ago about how long and where the detainees were held at the site,” Davenport wrote.
The attorney general said the state may seek a court conference if federal officials fail to provide the contract or answer questions about whether they are complying with the May order. But she said there’s no need to set a new court schedule for a possible renewed preliminary injunction motion until federal officials finish the environmental review.
“The parties can propose a schedule for future proceedings, including any renewed preliminary injunction motion, if and when an [environmental assessment] is completed,” Davenport said.
Steve Janoski is an award-winning investigative journalist with nearly two decades of experience covering criminal justice, policing, courts, government, and politics. His reporting has exposed corruption, government malfeasance, and police misconduct. His work has appeared in the New York Post, USA Today, The Associated Press, The Record, and the Asbury Park Press. At The Jersey Vindicator, he covers criminal justice. Reach Steve at steve AT jerseyvindicator.org.


