Skip to content
Email Signal messenger iconBluesky social media iconFacebook Instagram RSS
The Jersey Vindicator logoThe Jersey Vindicator logo
Newsletter

Insert HTML here

Bold reporting for a brighter New Jersey
  • NJ Public ToolboxExpand
    • Follow the money NJExpand
      • Pay to play rankings
      • Legislator profiles
    • Nursing home dataExpand
      • Nursing home donation tracker
      • Nursing home PAC donation tracker
      • 🔍 NJ Nursing Home Owner Search Tool
      • 🔍 NJ Nursing Home Owners – Other States
  • Bill TrackerExpand
    • Bill search tool
    • Latest New Jersey bills
    • Top bill sponsors
    • Call It! Play our bill guessing game
  • State Govt
  • Criminal Justice
  • Healthcare
  • AffordabilityExpand
    • Housing
  • Environment
  • Immigration
  • Elections
  • OpinionExpand
    • The Public Record
    • What’s Left
    • Pinelands Matters
  • 📧 Newsletter Signup
  • ❤️ Support Our Work
The Jersey Vindicator logoThe Jersey Vindicator logo

What's Left Commentary

U.S. Senate permitting bill puts New Jersey’s clean water protections at risk

ByJeff Tittel Nov 20, 2026Nov 20, 2026
EmailSubscribeWhatsAppSMSShare

The bill would give the state less say over projects like gas pipelines, shorten the time residents have to challenge federal approvals, and leave questions about who pays to power data centers.

Democrats have a habit of snatching defeat from the jaws of victory. On Nov. 3, voters handed them control of Congress and a chance to put a check on President Donald Trump’s agenda. Six days later, 21 Senate Democrats and an independent who caucuses with them helped Republicans advance a bill that would weaken some of the most important environmental protections we have.

Democrats could have used that first vote to stop the bill and waited until their new majority took office in January. They could have brought newly elected senators into the negotiations and pushed for a bill that speeds up clean energy, protects consumers, and preserves New Jersey’s authority over projects that threaten its rivers and wetlands. Instead, they gave Republicans the votes to move ahead in the lame-duck session.

The Senate passed the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act on Nov. 19, 62–33. Fourteen Democrats, including Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, voted for it. So did Maine independent Angus King. The bill now goes back to the House.

Supporters say faster approvals for power plants and transmission lines will help lower energy costs. The bill could speed up some renewable energy projects and make large data centers cover more of the costs they create. It would also make it easier to approve fossil fuel projects, give New Jersey less say over how pipelines affect its waters, and leave residents with fewer ways to challenge federal permits. That is the price the bill’s supporters are asking us to pay for the promise of lower electric bills.

How New Jersey’s senators voted

The first chance to stop the bill came on Nov. 9, when the Senate needed 60 votes to end debate on whether to take it up. Fifty-one Republicans voted yes, leaving them nine votes short. They got 22 votes from the Democratic caucus, including one from New Jersey Sen. Andy Kim. Sen. Cory Booker voted no. The motion carried 73–25.

Some Democrats who voted yes said they would try to improve the bill through amendments. By Nov. 18, the Senate had adopted a revised version, and opposition had grown. Kim joined Booker in voting against ending debate on the amended bill. But 15 members of the Democratic caucus still voted with Republicans, and the motion carried 65–31. Both New Jersey senators voted against final passage the next day.

I was disappointed to see Kim vote to advance the bill. To his credit, he changed course. But voting to move a bad bill forward on the promise of fixing it later is like buying a house with a collapsing foundation because somebody promises to repair it after you move in.

Republicans held 53 Senate seats. They needed help from Democrats to clear the 60-vote hurdles, but final passage required only a simple majority. Democrats could have used either procedural vote to insist on a better bill. By the time the Senate voted on passage, Republicans had the votes to pass it on their own.

New Jersey would lose leverage over pipelines.

One of the most dangerous provisions weakens Section 401 of the Clean Water Act, which gives states an important role in protecting their waters from federally licensed projects. States can require developers to take steps to protect water quality or deny certification when a project fails to meet water quality standards.

New Jersey has used this authority to fight destructive projects, including the PennEast and Northeast Supply Enhancement pipelines. PennEast’s developers canceled the project in 2021 after they failed to obtain New Jersey’s water quality certification and wetlands permits, even though federal regulators had approved the pipeline.

In 2019, New Jersey turned down the Northeast Supply Enhancement application after the developer failed to show how dredging in Raritan Bay would meet state water quality standards. Sediment samples had raised concerns about mercury and other contaminants. New Jersey approved a later application in November 2025, but a federal appeals court threw out the water quality certification in September. The court found the state had failed to adequately explain how the project would meet its water quality standards. The developer reapplied on Nov. 13.

The Senate bill narrows what states can consider in these reviews, restricts the conditions they can impose, and gives them no more than nine months to decide on certifications for certain interstate gas pipelines and power lines. For those projects, the review would focus on direct discharges from identifiable sources. Imagine trying to protect a river when your review is limited to what comes out of one pipe. What happens to the rest of the watershed?

The legislation also extends the maximum term for certain water pollution permits and general dredging and fill permits from five years to 10. That means permits can remain in place longer before they are revisited, even as conditions in a watershed change and new environmental problems emerge.

Now combine that with the Trump administration’s push to narrow which wetlands federal law protects and New Jersey’s own push to expedite permitting. A public dashboard can help people see where an application stands. But when Washington weakens the rules, Congress restricts what states can review, and Trenton presses its agencies to move faster, the public loses protection at every level. New Jersey should be strengthening the safeguards it uses to protect its own waters.

Developers get a fast pass, communities get a stopwatch

The National Environmental Policy Act is one of the most important environmental laws in the country. It requires federal agencies to examine the environmental consequences of major projects, consider alternatives, and allow the public to participate.

The bill narrows the scope of environmental reviews, limits the alternatives agencies must consider, and restricts when they must examine new scientific information. It also calls for the use of artificial intelligence to help agencies review projects and process permit applications.

The legislation sets a 150-day deadline for certain lawsuits under the law and limits when courts can set aside permits or stop work. In other words, developers get a fast pass while communities get a stopwatch.

Imagine a community trying to review thousands of pages of technical documents about a pipeline, transmission line, or industrial project. Residents need time to understand the science, consult experts, identify problems, and organize a response. Under this legislation, they would have less time to build a case. Even if a judge finds the review deficient and sends it back to the agency, the permit would generally stay in effect while the agency fixes it. By the time the review is corrected, trees could already be cleared or a stream disturbed.

Endangered species, public lands, and tribal rights

The Endangered Species Act is supposed to ensure that federal agencies do not jeopardize threatened and endangered species or destroy critical habitat. The bill would shorten the standard deadline for formal consultation from 90 days to 60 and let states take on some federal consultation duties. Wildlife does not recognize state boundaries. Migratory birds, fish, and other species move across entire regions. Shifting those responsibilities to individual states risks inconsistent standards and weaker protections.

The bill also changes how federal agencies review projects under the National Historic Preservation Act. It tightens deadlines and changes how agencies consult with state and tribal historic preservation officials. Pipelines and other infrastructure can cross ancestral lands and disturb burial grounds or sacred sites. These places are living connections to Native cultures, ancestral homelands, and generations of tradition. When the timetable for consultation gets shorter, tribal nations have less time to document what a project could destroy and to press agencies to change its route or design.

Public lands belong to all of us. They should serve the people who hike and fish on them and the communities that depend on clean water downstream. The legislation would make it easier to move ahead with some projects on public lands, including certain oil and gas activities and work along existing utility corridors. Industrial development gets the express lane, while conservation, public recreation, and tribal concerns are pushed to the back of the line.

The same communities pay the price

The people who benefit from these projects often live far from the people who have to live with them. Corporate developers and energy companies get the profits, while low-income communities, communities of color, and tribal nations are left with the pollution, health risks, and loss of land.

Pipelines, power lines, substations, and gas plants cut through neighborhoods, forests, farms, and culturally significant landscapes. They bring construction noise, air pollution, habitat destruction, and, in some cases, the risk of leaks or spills. When environmental reviews are shortened, and residents have fewer ways to challenge permits, the communities already carrying the heaviest pollution burden lose some of their most important tools to fight back.

Look at the Ironbound in Newark. It is an overburdened community already surrounded by industrial pollution, heavy truck traffic, port operations, and a garbage incinerator. Adding another source of pollution in a neighborhood like this is a public health issue. Residents need a chance to ask what a new project would add to the pollution they already live with. Ironbound Community Corporation

That question came up when the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission sought to build a gas-fired backup power plant at its Newark wastewater treatment facility. Backup power can keep the plant running during a blackout. The Ironbound Community Corporation challenged the state air permit, arguing that New Jersey failed to adequately consider the additional pollution the plant would bring to an already overburdened neighborhood. The people who live nearby deserve to have that question answered before the state approves the project. Permit challenge

New transmission lines and gas infrastructure built to serve power plants and energy-intensive data centers can also cut through overburdened communities. The pollution does not disappear because the electricity is being sent somewhere else. A gas plant still burns fuel, emits pollution, and contributes to climate change. Some communities get the power, while others get the pollution.

Expanding fossil fuel infrastructure can lock in decades of greenhouse gas emissions and make it harder to meet our climate goals. Communities already vulnerable to flooding, extreme heat, and poor air quality are hit hardest. You cannot claim to be making energy more affordable while sacrificing the health and safety of communities that have already paid the highest price.

Nuclear power shows what faster approvals can mean

Nuclear power is another example of how these policies work together. The Trump administration is pushing small modular reactors and has directed the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to set an 18-month deadline for deciding whether to license new reactors for construction and operation. The commission has also moved to speed up hearings when a license application is contested. White House executive order summary · Federal Register

Now add the Senate bill. It would change licensing hearings and set deadlines for certain nuclear facilities. Its broader permitting changes could also speed up approvals for the transmission lines and other infrastructure those projects need.

New Jersey is moving in the same direction. Gov. Mikie Sherrill signed the Power NJ Act in July, and state regulators have begun setting up a process to solicit interest in advanced nuclear projects. The federal government will decide whether to license a reactor. New Jersey officials will have to weigh what a project would mean for local communities and how much it could cost ratepayers. Power NJ Act

Nuclear power plants are complex, expensive, and potentially dangerous facilities. Their impacts do not stop at the fence line. A community needs to know where a plant will get its cooling water, who would be covered by its emergency plans, and how radioactive waste will be managed over the long term. Those questions apply to small modular reactors, too.

Washington is shortening the licensing timetable, Congress is moving to speed up permitting, and New Jersey is looking for developers. Communities need meaningful opportunities to examine the risks, question the science, and challenge inadequate reviews. A nuclear project does not become safer because Washington wants it built faster.

Project certainty for polluters, uncertainty for the public

Perhaps the most outrageous provisions are the so-called project certainty protections. Section 1401 would make it much harder for federal agencies to revoke, suspend, or change certain permits. There are exceptions, including for court orders and certain violations of federal law or material permit conditions. But permit holders could sue, and if the agency failed to justify its action, a court could reinstate the permit and award certain costs associated with delays. A finding of bad faith could bring additional compensation.

Section 1402 goes even further. Developers of certain projects could sue if they could show that the federal government intentionally engaged in a pattern of improperly denying or unreasonably delaying permits. If they met the bill’s other requirements, they could recover economic damages and, in some cases, compensation tied to construction costs.

Think about what that means. A future administration could discover serious environmental problems with a project and face an expensive legal fight if it tries to change or revoke the permit. At the same time, the bill restricts what courts can do when residents challenge the original approval. The developer gets the protection, and taxpayers could get stuck with the bill.

The renewable energy Trojan horse

Supporters of the bill argue that it is necessary to speed up wind, solar, battery storage, and transmission projects. There are real problems with the nation’s grid. Renewable energy projects can wait years for a connection, and the bill would give some projects a faster path forward. Its protections for existing permits could also help clean energy developers.

But protecting a permit already in hand is one thing. Getting the Trump administration to issue a new one is another. The administration has already reached deals with developers to give up offshore wind leases and redirect investment toward fossil fuel and other energy projects. There is little reason to assume the bill will end the administration’s resistance to new wind projects. Reuters

Meanwhile, oil and gas developers would get new advantages, including exemptions from environmental review for certain activities at existing sites or along existing corridors. Some of those projects would also qualify for the same permit protections the bill’s sponsors are touting for clean energy. That’s the Trojan horse. The promise of faster renewable energy is being used to sell a much broader rollback that benefits the fossil fuel industry.

We want renewable energy. We want transmission lines where they are needed. We can build both while protecting wetlands, forests, wildlife habitat, and public lands.

Who pays to power data centers?

Big Tech’s race to build artificial intelligence infrastructure is driving demand for enormous amounts of electricity. Large data centers can require new transmission lines, substations, power plants, and other grid upgrades. The companies creating that demand should pay the costs.

The bill would bar utilities from passing the additional retail costs they identify for serving a data center on to other customers. That protection matters. So does how utilities and regulators decide which costs the data center caused in the first place. If a transmission line is built primarily to serve a data center but also improves reliability for the region, who decides how much the company pays and how much goes on everyone else’s electric bill?

Then there is the problem of stranded infrastructure. What happens if a company builds a massive data center, drives expensive grid investments, and then closes or moves? The infrastructure debt does not simply disappear. The bill would require utilities to structure rates or agreements so they can keep collecting the additional retail costs from the company even after it stops buying power. Regulators still have to make sure the estimates cover the investments made to serve the facility and that utilities can collect what the company owes.

New Jersey families and small businesses should be able to see those numbers up front. How much does the utility expect to spend? How much has the data center agreed to pay? If the bill’s promise is affordability, those are the questions the public needs answered.

The House still has a choice

There are legitimate problems with the federal permitting system. Renewable energy projects, transmission lines, and critical infrastructure can get caught in unnecessary delays. Congress can give agencies the staff they need to review applications, coordinate their work, and make it easier for residents to see what’s proposed and weigh in while there is still time to make changes.

We can speed up clean energy without giving fossil fuel companies a blank check. We can build transmission without sacrificing wetlands and public lands. We can make data centers pay their fair share without leaving families to cover the cost of serving them.

Senate Democrats could have waited until January and used their new majority to fight for that kind of bill. Enough of them chose to help Republicans push this one through before the new Congress took office. The House still has a chance to insist on a bill that protects clean water, gives communities a meaningful voice, and makes good on its promise to lower costs.

A bipartisan sellout is still a sellout. And calling it affordability does not make it affordable.

U.S. Senate permitting bill puts New Jersey’s clean water protections at risk
Jeff Tittel
+ postsBio ⮌

Jeff Tittel is an environmental and political activist, the founder of SOAR, and the former director of the New Jersey Sierra Club.

  • Jeff Tittel
    Fourteen years after Sandy, New Jersey is more vulnerable than ever
  • Jeff Tittel
    New Jersey is gambling on AI: Will taxpayers roll snake eyes on CoreWeave?
  • Jeff Tittel
    NJ’s nuclear power task farce: A corporate giveaway disguised as energy policy
  • Jeff Tittel
    Affordable housing or developer giveaway?

Post navigation

Previous Previous
New Jersey puts liquor license records online

The Jersey Vindicator is a proud member of the following organizations:

Institute for Nonprofit News member badge
Association of Alternative Newsmedia logo
Investigative Reporters and Editors (IRE) logo
New Jersey Center for Nonprofits logo
NJ News Commons at Montclair State University member badge
New Jersey Civic Information Consortium member badge
The Jersey Vindicator logo in white

Independent, nonprofit investigative journalism that holds power accountable, makes complex issues understandable, and gives New Jersey residents the information they need to make informed decisions.

  • Republishing our stories
  • Conflicts of interest policy
  • Diversity of funding policy
  • Editorial Independence Policy
  • Journalistic ethics
  • Collaborations
  • How to contact us
  • Our mission
  • Contributors
  • How we’re funded
  • How to support our work

© 2026 The New Jersey Center for Nonprofit Journalism

Email Bluesky social network butterfly logoLinkedin Facebook Instagram RSS
  • NJ Public Toolbox
    • Follow the money NJ
      • Pay to play rankings
      • Legislator profiles
    • Nursing home data
      • Nursing home donation tracker
      • Nursing home PAC donation tracker
      • 🔍 NJ Nursing Home Owner Search Tool
      • 🔍 NJ Nursing Home Owners – Other States
  • Bill Tracker
    • Bill search tool
    • Latest New Jersey bills
    • Top bill sponsors
    • Call It! Play our bill guessing game
  • State Govt
  • Criminal Justice
  • Healthcare
  • Affordability
    • Housing
  • Environment
  • Immigration
  • Elections
  • Opinion
    • The Public Record
    • What’s Left
    • Pinelands Matters
  • 📧 Newsletter Signup
  • ❤️ Support Our Work
Search
Share to...
FacebookBlueskyThreadsRedditXLinkedInMessengerNextdoorFlipboardPrintMastodon