Details don’t add up in anonymous letter accusing Trenton mayor of abuse
Former Councilwoman Robin Vaughn, who has a long and acrimonious history with Mayor W. Reed Gusciora, posted the unsigned letter on Facebook two weeks after he advanced to a runoff election

Former Trenton Councilwoman Robin Vaughn posted an anonymous letter on Facebook on Monday, Nov. 16, in which the writer accused Mayor W. Reed Gusciora of sexually abusing him as a 14-year-old in 1998 at Gusciora’s Princeton home at 20 MacLean St.
But public records show that Gusciora did not live at that address in 1998. The house hadn’t even been built yet.
Property records reviewed by The Jersey Vindicator this week show that the home at 20 MacLean St. in Princeton’s Witherspoon-Jackson neighborhood referenced in the letter was built in 2001 as part of a six-unit mixed-income development called the Kathleen Edwards Houses.
Gusciora bought his home on MacLean Street in 2002, four years after the alleged incidents occurred at the house, county deed and mortgage records obtained by The Vindicator show. Before that, Gusciora lived in a studio apartment at 166 Nassau St., according to federal and state campaign finance filings and other records reviewed by The Vindicator.
Don’t miss the NJ stories that matter. Sign up for our free newsletter →
Vaughn’s Monday Facebook post was headed “ALERT! PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT.” It linked to the full anonymous letter on Google Drive. By the time The Vindicator viewed it, the post had been shared 54 times.
The post was still up Friday when The Vindicator emailed Vaughn for comment. Later that day, it was gone. Vaughn did not respond to questions from The Vindicator on Friday.
Contacted about the letter Friday evening, Gusciora told The Vindicator he had hired a lawyer in response to Vaughn’s post.
“The letter is absurd, but the damage has been done because now it’s reverberated around Facebook and keeps popping up,” he said.
The letter was mailed four days after Gusciora was forced into a runoff for mayor with police detective Corey McNair. McNair finished first on Nov. 3 with about 37% of the vote. Gusciora, a two-term incumbent, finished second with about 23%. The runoff is Dec. 8.
The Vindicator is not publishing the letter, which contains graphic descriptions of alleged sexual encounters. The letter also includes detailed descriptions of a house, rooms, furniture, a housemate, and a backyard at 20 MacLean St. According to the letter, Gusciora paid the 14-year-old to mow weeds in his backyard with an electric lawnmower, then gave him a beer and touched him.
Not only did Gusciora not live at 20 MacLean St. when the alleged sexual encounters took place, but the house built at that address had no backyard, only a paved parking lot directly behind it. In 1998, the studio apartment Gusciora lived in on Nassau Street also did not have a front or back yard and was surrounded by pavement.
The Vindicator contacted a former neighbor of Gusciora’s whose recollections of dates related to the housing development match public records.
Kevin Wilkes, an architect and former Princeton councilman, told The Vindicator he lived two doors down from Gusciora for five years, at 16 MacLean St. The housing development never had backyards, just a parking lot, he noted.
Wilkes, who lived there from 2005-2010, does not recall seeing men or boys coming in or out of Gusciora’s house.
“In my five years living two doors away from Reed, the only people I saw him bring in and out were his mom and his sister, Holly,” Wilkes said.
The post
Vaughn posted the letter at 1:53 p.m. Monday. She wrote that she had received it in the mail from a man identifying himself as “John Doe.”
Her post did not name Gusciora. It said the man accused of the abuse, “Walt” or “Reed,” was someone the writer believed to be “serving as the current mayor of the City of Trenton.”
Vaughn wrote that she had notified county, state, and federal law enforcement and asked for an investigation. She called the claims “grave allegations.”
She also acknowledged that the claims had not been established as fact.
“The letter alone does not establish accuracy, any person’s identity, or criminal responsibility,” she wrote.
Despite that warning, Vaughn shared a link to the entire letter, making its allegations available to the public just weeks before the mayoral runoff.
The post asked readers not to “post suspected identities, speculate about guilt, confront anyone, or circulate threats.” It listed contacts at the Mercer County Prosecutor’s Office and the state Attorney General’s Office.
Vaughn limited who could comment on the Facebook post.
The letter
The five-page typed letter is addressed to Vaughn, who ran against Gusciora for mayor in 2022. The return address on the envelope is also Vaughn’s. It was postmarked in Philadelphia on Nov. 7.
The writer says he is an Army sergeant major. He says that in August 1998, he was 14 and hanging restaurant menus on doorknobs in Princeton. He says a man who called himself “Walt” and “Reed” hired him for chores, including mowing weeds in his backyard with an electric mower, and then fondled him on four Saturdays that month.
Gusciora’s legal name is Walter Reed Gusciora. He goes by W. Reed. In 1998, he was a state assemblyman.
The writer says his mother signed a nondisclosure agreement in September 1998 in exchange for $2,000, and that his brother found it two years ago. No copy was included with the letter.
He says he cannot come forward publicly but would testify as “John Doe” in a closed hearing.
The letter asks Vaughn to share the story. It also says Gusciora “deserves to be hanged.”
What the records show
On May 30, 2000, Gusciora filed a statement of candidacy with the Federal Election Commission for a congressional run. He listed his address as 166 Nassau St. in Princeton. He lived there for several years, according to public records reviewed by The Vindicator.
The house at 20 MacLean St. was built in 2001. On Aug. 26, 2002, a deed and mortgage for 20 MacLean St. were recorded with the Mercer County clerk, with Gusciora listed as the borrower.
Gusciora lived on MacLean Street for about nine years. In 2011, after redistricting moved Princeton out of his Assembly district, he put the house on the market and moved to Trenton.
Other letter details
The writer says he was stationed in South Korea for the past 10 years. He says he is home on “R&R” and will be “redeployed” soon.
He says South Korea executes drug dealers with lethal doses of heroin. South Korea has not carried out an execution since 1997.
He says he was visiting his mother in Trenton. The letter was mailed from Philadelphia.
The address on the envelope was printed by computer.
The copy of the letter Vaughn posted was scanned on Nov. 10, according to the file’s metadata, six days before it was shared on Facebook. The envelope was scanned after the letter.
Vaughn and Gusciora
Vaughn publicly accused Gusciora of pedophilia while she served on the Trenton City Council.
During a conference call on May 2, 2020, Gusciora asked Vaughn about a social media post in which she accused him of supporting “do nothing nonprofit organizations.” The exchange escalated.
According to audio later released by the mayor’s office, Vaughn told him: “You are a big fat idiot, f—ing drug addict, pedophile, that’s what you are … you’re a pedophile … you need to get the f— out of office and get the f— out of Trenton.”
At another point, she said, “You’re nothing but an old pedophile.”
The exchange made national headlines. Vaughn also said that “the only thing [Gusciora] brought into City Hall is a bunch of young boys, and they’re sitting up there in the mayor’s suite.” She also suggested the mayor and Councilman Joe Harrison were in a sexual relationship.
Gusciora called Vaughn a “child” and an “idiot.” Afterward, he said in a statement that she had chosen “to launch into a vitriolic attack full of homophobic slurs, false accusations, and hateful comments.”
The pedophilia accusation spread online. Gusciora reported threats he had received online to local police. Twitter users repeated Vaughn’s accusation that Gusciora was a pedophile as if it were fact.
Lt. Gov. Sheila Oliver, Garden State Equality, the LGBTQ Victory Fund, and the state Democratic chairman called on Vaughn to resign. In a 5-2 vote, the council declined to censure her; Jerell Blakeley and Joe Harrison were the only ones to vote in favor of censure.
Days later, Vaughn issued an apology on her Facebook page but told an NJ.com reporter via text message that she would not step down.
“I apologize. That must be the first thing you hear from me. I am deeply and specifically sorry for the language that has offended so many,” she wrote.
About three hours later, she posted another message that read, “Robin Vaughn, West Ward Councilwoman. 100% self-funded elected official.”
In 2022, Vaughn challenged Gusciora for mayor and finished third, behind Gusciora and Kathy McBride. She left the council at the end of that year.
On the campaign trail
Gusciora said the anonymous letter has followed him around the city this week. While he was campaigning in the Island neighborhood on Friday, a resident told him she had received the email.
“Later, while walking, all of a sudden I got ambushed by men who were waving it in my face,” he said.
McNair also posted a video of Gusciora wearing a long blonde wig and a white chicken dress. Gusciora was referred to as a “racist queen.”
A video of McNair in a chicken suit had circulated earlier in the week. McNair has refused to debate Gusciora and has declined interviews with the press since the Nov. 3 election.
Gusciora, 66, is seeking a third term. He is Trenton’s first openly gay mayor. He served in the Assembly from 1996 until he became mayor in 2018.
Gusciora said the letter has diverted attention from the challenges facing Trenton.
“It’s unfortunate,” he said. “We should be discussing the issues.”
Building a more informed New Jersey, one story at a time.
Readers fund The Jersey Vindicator because they believe New Jersey needs independent reporting that serves the public. No paywall. No spin. Just deeply reported journalism that helps people understand what’s happening in our state.
If you believe this work matters, please contribute today.
Krystal Knapp is the founder, executive director, and publisher of The Jersey Vindicator and the founder of Planet Princeton. She has more than two decades of experience reporting in New Jersey, including 10 years at The Trenton Times, where she was the newsroom’s public records and computer-assisted reporting expert. Her work has been recognized by the New Jersey Press Association and the Center for Cooperative Media. You can reach her at Krystal AT jerseyvindicator.org.

